Therapy dogs - abuse or aid?
Beardwood House
Who really benefits from therapy dogs Therapy dogs have proven to be a helpful tool in providing comfort and support to schoolchildren- especially those who suffer from mental illness, or victims of violence. So, what could be wrong with utilising dogs for the benefit of children? There are many opinions on the ethics of this, so read on to find out more... Spending time with dogs in a therapeutic setting can help to relax the person and encourages them to open up more. There is also no denying that dogs are comforting and provide a safe atmosphere. In many cases, therapy dogs enjoy and become enriched by these sessions, as they become sociable, and some enjoy being the centre of attention! Unfortunately, there are also some cons to the use of therapy dogs, as there are also people who disagree with the use of therapy dogs. There is evidence to suggest that dogs can become stressed by being around anxious or distressed people. Schools can be an especially taxing environment to be in, as they can be noisy and echo-y. There is also a risk that when a dog becomes agitated, there is a chance that they can be taught to suppress emotions and can lead to a complete shutdown.

We interviewed Year 9 Student, Isla about her opinions on the use of a therapy dog at Colfe’s School. When asked how therapy dogs could be beneficial to students, her response was- ‘Although therapy dogs can be relaxing, they pose a substantial risk to students with fears of dogs, or with allergies to dogs.’ She also thinks that there is a risk of danger to dogs, especially if they do not have the correct training. ‘I think that dogs can easily become frustrated in these types of situations, and they could also be wrongfully punished for being jumpy or biting people who get too close. Overall, the risks that dogs and humans are faced with are not worth it.’ We also interviewed our Head of Learning Support; Miss Coode about the service of therapy dogs, and here are her opinions; ‘It is very well known that dogs, and all pets, are very soothing, so having access to an animal that is naturally calm will be good for everyone.’ She acknowledges the risks of using these dogs, but believes that with limited access to the animal, and with regular breaks for the dog, they would be widely beneficial for everyone in the school.


Comments